International P2P Lending Volumes August 2017

The table lists the loan originations of p2p lending marketplaces for last month. Funding Circle leads ahead of Zopa and Ratesetter. The total volume for the reported platforms adds up to 391 million Euro. I track the development of p2p lending volumes for many markets. Since I already have most of the data on file, I can publish statistics on the monthly loan originations for selected p2p lending platforms.

Milestones reached this month are:

  • Bondora reaches 100 million Euro in financed loans since launch

Investors living in national markets with no or limited selection of local p2p lending services can check this list of international investing on p2p lending services. Investors can also explore how to make use of current p2p lending cashback offers available. UK investors can compare IFISA rates.

Want to meet representatives of many of the listed companies? Attend Lendit London in October -use discount code WiseclerkVip to get a 15% rebate on registration.

P2P Lending Statistic August 2017
Table: P2P Lending Volumes in August 2017. Source: own research

Note that volumes have been converted from local currency to Euro for the purpose of comparison. Some figures are estimates/approximations.
*Prosper and Lending Club no longer publish origination data for the most recent month.

Notice to p2p lending services not listed: Continue reading

Funding Circle Stops to Offer Manual Investment in Self Selected Loans

Funding Cirlce LogoUK p2p lending Marketplace Funding Circle announced today that from September 18th, there will be an important change to how investors can invest on the marketplace. From that date Funding Circle will withdraw the option to manually choose which businesses to lend to and which loan parts to sell. Instead Funding Circle says it will launch a significantly improved and upgraded version of existing Autobid and Autosell lending tools.

Investors will be able to choose one of two new lending options based on their personal preference. Both options will be available as a Funding Circle ISA, which Funding Circle intends to launch later this tax year.

  • Balanced: you will automatically lend to the full range of creditworthy businesses (A+ to E), aiming to achieve an attractive, stable return. This will allow you to build a balanced portfolio similar to the makeup of small businesses in the UK today. The projected return is estimated to be 7.5% per year after fees and bad debt.
  • Conservative: you will focus on lending to businesses that have been assessed as lower risk (initially A+/A) but with a lower projected return. The projected return is estimated to be 4.8% per year after fees and bad debt.

Funding Circle gives the following reasons for stopping manual lending:

We launched Funding Circle in 2010 with the option for investors to either manually choose which businesses to lend to, or use our Autobid tool to build a portfolio based on their lending preferences. While many investors have enjoyed manually choosing loans, there are some drawbacks to it:

  • Many investors do not currently benefit from lending to all types of businesses: currently some investors can find it difficult to access D and E loans, which are some of the most popular. We want to ensure investors lending through Funding Circle have an equal chance of accessing all loans, and earn the best possible return.
  • It can mean your lending is not spread evenly across lots of businesses: currently many investors who manually choose loans are not fully diversified and are at risk of having a negative lending experience. We want to ensure investors spread their lending across lots of different businesses as this is the best way to earn a stable return.
  • It can be confusing for investors: many investors tell us they prefer a simpler, easy-to-use lending experience: 73% of new investors who join Funding Circle choose Autobid, and 80% of Funding Circle investors* say simplicity of lending is important to them.

* Independently surveyed by Cambridge University

Funding Circle will also make changes to the interest rates effective August 30th. Funding Circle says ‘When reviewing rates we take a number of factors into account, including macroeconomic trends, the expected mix of risk bands of borrowers, expected bad debt rates and wider competition in the market, which continues to be increasingly competitive for lower risk businesses. The new rates will allow you to continue to lend to established, creditworthy small businesses while earning an attractive, stable return.’.

Furthermore Funding Circle has removes sales fees for selling loans, effective today. There will be no more premiums and discounts possible on the secondary market.

Several p2p lending services have made similar moves discontinuing self-selection of loans to invest into and asking investors to use autoinvest options instead usually citing simplicity and ease of use. While this may be true for part of investors it certainly is not true for all of the investors. Especially among most active and vocal investors there are some that like to select loans manually and dislike if that choice is removed (Funding Circle says 73% of new investors use autobid).

Possible as a result of sentiments like that Bondora reintroduced more selection options with their Portfoloio Pro feature, after removing them earlier.

 

Interview with Terry Fisher, Founder at Huddle Capital

What is Huddle Capital about?

Huddle Capital is a P2P lender specialising in high quality, high yielding business loans. In an already crowded space, Huddle is differentiating itself by it high quality origination and a focus on educating its lenders to help them make better decisions. Unlike many other Huddle Capital is backed by a parent company that has been lending its own money for a long time, which they will continue to lend though the Huddle platform – really putting our money where our mouth is!

The parent company underwrites each deal, which means that all borrowers will 100% get funded through our platform.  In addition, we offer investors instant returns – in other words, investors start earning as soon as they make a commitment to invest in a loan, regardless of how long it takes for a loan and get fully funded.

What are the three main advantages for investors?

The main advantage for lenders on Huddle is that we are owned and managed by Access Commercial Finance which is an FCA regulated, balance sheet lender. Our belief is that most fintech businesses in the marketplace are too much ‘tech’ and not enough ‘fin’ so we are looking to correct that balance on Huddle. There is no point having a fancy website & tech if the underlying loans are of poor quality and the collection process has holes in it. We are an existing finance business that has all the processes and knowledge in place already – we are simply bolting on the p2p tech to allow investors the opportunity to invest alongside us.

Investors benefit in 3 ways:

  1. We aim to provide higher returns compared with average returns in P2P market, by leveraging our loan management expertise. Naturally investors must balance risk versus reward.
  2. We provide instant returns to investors, as explained above; and
  3. We believe in empowering investors to make educated investment decisions, especially in this new asset class. We educate and provide a platform for investors to network with each other.

What are the three main advantages for borrowers?

The main advantage to borrowers is getting speedy access to funding for strong business cases that have been unable to achieve satisfactory funding elsewhere. This could be due to slow processing timescales by more mainstream lenders, or the fact that the borrower can’t find a lender who like their particular case / asset class etc.

At Huddle we share many of the same management team of Access Finance and therefore have a wealth of commercial business experience as owners as well as lenders, allowing us to understand borrowers needs better and quicker than most other lenders.

What ROI can investors expect?

As always, reward increases with perceived risk so individual lenders are free to choose the loans and risk profile that suits them. Currently we have loans that pay lenders from 8% to 16% per annum, depending on their risk appetite.

Naturally, ROI increases with the ability of the platform to manage bad debts.  Our parent, Access Commercial Finance, has only ever had minor default since they started lending.  We deploy the same credit management team who is proactive in chasing down late payments.

Why did Access Commercial Finance decide to start Huddle Capital?

At Access we have been originating a stream of good quality loans for many years and have had great success funding them from our own balance sheet. But we don’t have unlimited funds and often come across loans which we would like to be involved with but they need pricing more competitively than we are able to. So with Huddle we are looking to open up our origination channel to P2P investors, allowing us to write more business and not have to pass up great opportunities just because our own funding capabilities don’t allow it.

Terry FisherHuddle Capital is using technology supplied by Ablrate. What factors led to the choice of this solution and how satisfied are you with the software?

At Access we have had a fantastic working relationship with Ablrate for the last couple of years. We have originated a lot of high quality loans that Ablrate have funded through their investor base. We actually looked at a lot of software providers in the market and were not 100% happy with any of them. Then we thought ‘hang on a minute! Why aren’t we working with Ablrate on this?!’. 10 weeks later we were live! David at Ablrate is a very good operator and very commercial to work with, so the process was a breeze.

The Ablrate platform is proven – having gone through a stringent review by the FCA as part of the approval process.  We leverage their practical experience to ensure that we avoid mistakes made by the pioneering P2P industry.

Huddle Capital Limited is an Appointed Representative of Rebuildingsociety. What does that mean and why did you choose that structure?

In simple terms this mean Rebuildingsociety provide us our regulatory permissions whilst we await our own from the FCA. Getting directly authorised from the FCA is a long and laborious process. Becoming an Appointed Representative allows us to get up and running in a matter of weeks as opposed to potentially well over a year. It makes no differences to our lenders or borrowers, we are still governed by the same rules as everyone else for their protection. We will look to get our own permissions in the fullness of time, but right now we are concentrating on building the business.

What were the main challenges launching your platform in a competitive (crowded?) market?

Once your tech works there are only 2 real challenges in this business – attracting lenders and finding borrowers. Fortunately we have got plenty of borrowers both existing and in the pipeline – so our challenge is getting out there in front of more lenders so they can learn about our platform and the benefits of lending through Huddle. Hopefully this interview will help with that!

We had support from a progressive consultancy, Vedanvi, who helped us develop the strategy, build the business, operate it and then transfer it to our own internal team.  They have significant experience in this market space and we leveraged their expertise to ensure a smooth and successful launch.

Is Huddle Capital open to international investors?

International investors are welcome to invest through Huddle Capital.  As required by law, they have to undergo additional anti money laundering checks before they are allowed to invest on our platform.  Investors need to realise though that their loan contracts and their contract with us are governed by UK law.

Which marketing channels do you use to attract investors and borrowers?

Currently all our borrowers are generated via Access, our parent company. We have no shortage of quality businesses looking to borrow money!

We are marketing to investors through the usual channels of PPC & SEO, but the primary channel we use is content led marketing, providing educational led content, empowering potential lenders to understand the lending business better and be in a position to make informed lending decision.

Do you plan an IFISA product offer?

Yes we certainly do but realistically it will be a few months down the line. We have lots of additions to the platform & the technology over the coming months and it is a matter of getting our priorities in order. We have launched, we have tech that works and now we are starting to get a flow of strong and high yielding loans. We are currently concentrating on brining on new investors so we can ensure strong liquidity in both the primary and secondary markets. Then we will move on to getting the IFISA launched. It’s keeping us busy!

Where do you see Huddle Capital in 3 years?

Hopefully as a highly recognised brand name in the P2P space. We should have a large base of happy lenders who come to us time and again to deploy their money in to high yielding, secure opportunities. Just doing more of what we do now, and listening to our lenders and borrowers to keep improving!

P2P-Banking.com thanks Terry Fischer for the interview.

Dutch Insurance Aegon Will Fund 160M GBP Loans on Funding Circle UK

Today Aegon and Funding Circle announced a strategic long term partnership. Aegon will invest in loans to UK small businesses originated through p2p lending marketplace Funding Circle.

The partnership will see Aegon fund 160 million GBP of loans in the first 12 months under a framework agreement, with the intention to extend this step-by-step into a four year funding program. In the first year the investment will help approximately 2,600 UK businesses to access finance.

Aegon joins a wide range of investors lending directly to small businesses through Funding Circle, including 65,000 individuals, local councils, the government-owned British Business Bank, the European Investment Bank and other financial institutions. Funding Circle states, investors in the UK have earned an average 6.6% per year and 135 million GBP  of net interest over the last seven years.

The Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Stephen Barclay, said: ‘Small businesses are the lifeblood of our economy and it’s fantastic news that Aegon are investing through Funding Circle to help them thrive and grow. This partnership with one of the UK’s largest FinTech firms is further proof that the UK remains the global leader in FinTech. Aegon’s venture also shows that there is significant appetite for inward investment into the UK and we hope to see more deals of this scale in the future.’

Mike de Boer, CFO Aegon Bank NV said: ‘Funding Circle allows small businesses to access much needed funding. The strategic partnership we have signed with Funding Circle is another important step in the strategy of Aegon to cooperate with Fintech partners in the direct lending landscape. This partnership gives Aegon access to attractive small business loans over the next four years, which helps to further diversify our investment portfolio. High savings inflow of our successful Fintech Knab banking operation is used to invest in the Funding Circle loans.’

‘This agreement follows an extensive due diligence on the loan origination, compliance and risk-returns of the Funding Circle loans. Funding Circle has shown that their robust process, technology and financial innovation capabilities have a positive impact on the UK economy and small businesses in particular. Funding Circle provides quick and transparent funding to small businesses.’ Continue reading

International P2P Lending Volumes July 2017

The table lists the loan originations of p2p lending marketplaces in June. Zopa leads ahead of Funding Circle and Lendinvest. The total volume for the reported platforms adds up to 491 million Euro. I added Iuvo Group and Dofinance to the table. I track the development of p2p lending volumes for many markets. Since I already have most of the data on file, I can publish statistics on the monthly loan originations for selected p2p lending platforms.

Milestones reached this month are:

  • Zopa crosses 2.5 billion GBP originated since launch
  • Ratesetter crosses 2 billion GBP originated since launch
  • Mintos loan volume since launch now over 250 million Euro
  • Lendix reaches 100 million Euro in financed loans since launch

Investors living in national markets with no or limited selection of local p2p lending services can check this list of international investing on p2p lending services. Investors can also explore how to make use of current p2p lending cashback offers available. UK investors can compare IFISA rates.

P2P Lending statistics July 2017
Table: P2P Lending Volumes in July 2017. Source: own research

Note that volumes have been converted from local currency to Euro for the purpose of comparison. Some figures are estimates/approximations.
*Prosper and Lending Club no longer publish origination data for the most recent month.

Notice to p2p lending services not listed: Continue reading

International P2P Lending Volumes June 2017

The table lists the loan originations of p2p lending marketplaces in June. Funding Circle leads ahead of Zopa and Lendinvest. Assetz Capital makes a huge leap forward. The total volume for the reported platforms adds up to 530 million Euro. I track the development of p2p lending volumes for many markets. Since I already have most of the data on file, I can publish statistics on the monthly loan originations for selected p2p lending platforms.

Milestones reached this month are:

  • Twino reaches 150 million EUR in origination since launch

Investors living in national markets with no or limited selection of local p2p lending services can check this list of international investing on p2p lending services. Investors can also explore how to make use of current p2p lending cashback offers available. UK investors can compare IFISA rates.

p2p lending statistic june 2017
Table: P2P Lending Volumes in June 2017. Source: own research

Note that volumes have been converted from local currency to Euro for the purpose of comparison. Some figures are estimates/approximations.
*Prosper and Lending Club no longer publish origination data for the most recent month.

Notice to p2p lending services not listed: Continue reading

Plum Automates Investment in Ratesetter – Plum Equity Crowdfunding Pitch

Plum is another fintech that makes use of Ratesetter’s products through a cooperation. Plum is bot on Facebook messenger designed to automate savings for the user and to invest money on his behalf. Savings can currently be invested in Ratesetters rolling market. Plum is currently pitching to raise 700K GBP through a convertible with a valuation cap of 5M GBP on Seedrs. Watch the video for more information on the Plum product and pitch. The minimum investment for this equity crowdfunding campaign is 10 GBP. The pitch is EIS eligible (UK residents). Other investors include 200K US$ invested by VC 500 Startups. This pitch is not yet officially launched on Seedrs, but already open for investments. You can use P2P-Banking’s free notification service to be alerted of upcoming Seedrs pitches early and review them ahead of the crowd.

Competitors of Plum include Digit, Qapital, Clarity, Albert, Squirrel, Cleo and Savedroid.

The Plum pitch deck is  informative reading. To request that, login, click on ‘Documents’ in the pitch, and send a message to request the pitch deck.

Another example of an innovative cooperative cooperation making use of products of a p2p lending service is Commuterclub.

This article is not an investment advice. Investing in startups bears significant risks, including total loss of investment.

Shift of Demand on UK Property Marketplaces

The market situation on UK property marketplaces for bridge loans with high interest rates has turned drastically in the past 2 months. For a long time before there has usually been much more investor demand than could be soaked up by loan demand. That the situation has changed is most visible on the loans on offer (mostly through the secondary markets). There is currently nearly 8 million GBP on offer on Lendy (that was close to nil 8 weeks ago). At Moneything there is 2 million GBP on offer and at Fundingsecure 0.6 million GBP. Collateral recently raised the interest rate for new loans from 12 to 14%.

So what is causing this change? I will look at possible causes and measures the marketplaces could take to react.

  • Have property prices peaked?
    Building activity and property prices are influenced by the economy. This Guardian article says UK house prices fell three month in a row. Should investors think, the economic climate is cooling down, they might be more cautious as loans to property developers would be affected in a downturn.
  • Defaults are rising on Lendy
    Loans that are more than 180 days overdue are categorized as default loans on Lendy. There are now 19 loans in default, with the total loan amount in these loans adding up to 23 million GBP. While this does not mean that money will be lost – the loans are secured by the property, it makes investors cautious and hesitant, asking more questions about valuations and collection procedures.
  • Lenders might fear that the assets become increasingly illiquid
    Part of the attraction of Lendy and Moneything in the past (aside from the high interest rate) came from the fact that loans could be sold very fast, usually within hours for most loans that were not overdue. That has changed on Lendy and might be currently changing on Moneything. However with the queues for sales building up on Lendy it is too easy to just look at the nearly 8 million GBP on offer and deduct that it takes very long to sell loans. Not all loans are equally liquid. I sold 400 GBP of DFL025 recently. Despite over 35,000 GBP in the queue before me, my part sold within 3 days.
    A major factor with the longer selling times is that on Lendy, investors forego interest while the loan part is on sale. On Moneything it continues to accrue interest while on sale.
  • UK investors are increasing their stake in tax sheltered IFISA products
    That is my favourite explanation. The shift in the above markets 2 months ago coincides with the launch of many IFISA offers on other UK marketplaces. Lendy, Monything and Collateral currently do not offer IFISAs. Check the database for best IFISA rates of other marketplaces. Fundingsecure has an IFISA. I am not currently investing on Fundingsecure, therefore I am not as closely monitoring the market developments on Fundingsecure as on Lendy or Moneything. But it seems that investor demand on Fundingsecure has not changed as much as on Lendy or Moneything. It is obvious that UK investors will prefer to invest in IFISA offers, at least until their yearly allowance of 20,000 GBP is reached.
  • Brexit and pound uncertainty pause international investors
    All of the above platforms are open for international investors. I currently run a survey among German speaking investors on my German p2p lending forum. 31% precent of respondents have already invested on UK marketplaces. But 5% want to reduce their level of investment because of the uncertainty of the pound development and for this reason 20% will not consider to start on UK marketplaces.

So what could marketplaces do and what measures are they already taking?

  • Attract more investors, increase marketing spend
    I believe this is already happening. Lendy revamped the referral program as of June 1st and Collateral announced it will launch one soon. Lendy will sponsor the ‘Lendy Cowes week’ sailing regatta. I have doubts this will be cost effective, but its hard to tell from the outside without access to hard figures. I know of other p2p lending platforms that sponsored golf events in the hope of targeting and attracting the right audience and discontinued that (for reasons unknown to me).
  • Launch an IFISA
    Actually I think this would most profoundly change the situation for Lendy. However for that Lendy first needs to get full FCA approval. Moneything has recently said it has put an IFISA higher on the priority list, but it is still not imminent but planned for later this year.
  • Find ‘different’ sources of capital
    This could be institutional money. Or a differently structed offer like the Lendy bond. But it is to early to tell how the Lendy bond is taken up.
  • Raise interest rates
    Collateral has taken this step. And Moneything offered 1 percent more on a very large loan. I don’t think Lendy will take this route as it recently moved from 12% interest for all loans to a broader range of 7 to 12% interest rates.
  • Change the model of the secondary market
    Lendy and Moneything currently have secondary operating at par value. The investor community seems split. While some applaud the simplicity and ease of use of this model, others argue to allow discounts (and possibly premiums). One argument for discounts and premiums is that it might better match demand and supply. Counterarguments are that p2p lending is not a high volume market and variable pricing would not be suitable and that premiums will attract traders. Also some feel that seeing discounts will furthermore undermine trust and deter new investors from signing up.
  • Show recovery results and better communication and transparency of collection efforts
    Obviously full recovery on defaults would be a most effective measure to increase confidence and trust of investors. However this will take time and I don’t think haste would do the results good. Therefore the only thing Lendy could do short-term is communicate more and in more detail.

What is your opinion, dear reader?

P.S.: On the continent at Estateguru with its 10-12.5% interest property loans there is no change of market conditions. Investor demand continues to outstrip loan supply.

Assetz Capital Launches Property Secured Investment Account

P2P Lending marketplace Assetz Capital today announced the launch of another account type. The Property Secured Investment Account (PSIA) is marketed as a way to invest exclusively in property backed loans with automatic diversification intended to help investors spread their risk across a diverse range of lending. Every single loan considered for this account is automatically selected or rejected upon the basis of the level of property security that it offers. The loans automatically selected for investment by this account are only those that have no expected loss in the case of that loan defaulting in the future, even after any estimated recovery costs.

The target rate for the Assetz PSIA account is 5.5%. (Interest is quoted gross at the target rate, although actual returns could be lower)

Assetz Capital Review – 30 Days Access Account with 4.75% Target Rate

Recently I opened an account at p2p lending marketplace Assetz Capital to gain some first hand experiences. Assetz Capital offers secured business loans to small and medium British SMEs. I decided to start with the 30 days access account as it is mostly hands off and deposited a tiny amount, which was credited within an hour. It currently offers a promotional target rate of 4.75% (instead of 4.25%) and allows to withdraw funds with 30 days notice in normal market conditions. Investors, who want to benefit from the promotional rate need to act now, as it is only applicable for deposits made until 11.59am on 6th June 2017 and is valid for a maximum of 90 days from the date of the deposit.

Assetz Capital has a minimum investment amount of 1 GBP. Assetz is open to international investors, but a UK bank account is required. If you do not have one, I suggest opening one at Transferwise. (UPDATE: but do check comment below this article, also see my Transferwise Borderless account article). All Assetz Capital (except the MLIA) investment accounts are protected by a provision fund. There are no fees for investors.

Assetz Capital says the 30 days access account is extremly popular with investors. Since the promotion offer was launched 7 weeks ago, 23 million GBP have been deposited in this account. Assetz also offers a quick access account with 3.75% target rate, designed to provide immediate access to cash, in normal market conditions, for investors. Currently 19 million GBP are invested in this account. Further account types are the ‘Great British Business Account’ (GBBA) with 7% target rate, the ‘Green Energy Income Account’ (GEIA) with 7% target rate and the ‘Manual Loan Investment Account’ (MLIA) with 5.5% to 18% gross rate. See comparison of Assetz accounts. Assetz also features a secondary market without fees providing liquidity.